[The are the last 4 days to contribute to The Wild Hunt Fall Funding Drive. We are now 68% funded. Help us reach 100%! All of our articles take time, research and money to produce. It is you that makes it all possible! Share our IndieGoGo link. Donate today and be part of the team that helps keeps The Wild Hunt going for another year. Thank You.]
PENSACOLA, Fla – It was announced Tuesday that the Escambia County Sheriff’s Office (ECSO) had made progress in the July triple homicide dubbed the ‘Blue Moon’ murders. Donald Wayne Hartung Sr, age 58, was arrested the morning of Oct 27 for the murder of his mother Voncile ‘Bonnie’ Smith (age 76) and his two half brothers Richard Thomas Smith (age 49) and John William Smith (age 47). Hartung is being held in the Escambia County jail without bond.
The case, as originally reported, was labeled the ‘Blue Moon’ murders after Sheriff David Morgan linked the case to that week’s blue moon. He called the murder “ritualistic” and the scene “odd at best.” Additionally, during the Aug. 4 news conference, Morgan reported that the case was connected to Witchcraft, which set off a week-long international media frenzy.
Over the past three months, there has been no public updates on the investigation. Then, on Tuesday, ECSO announced Hartung’s arrest and, subsequently, held a press conference. According to the Sheriff Morgan, the crime scene was confusing with “significant forensic evidence.” This was corroborated by State Attorney Bill Eddins, who said that it was one of the “most complicated he’d seen in his career.” They both cited this factor as the reason for the delays in making an arrest and updating the public.
When asked more specifically about the motive, Sheriff Morgan said, “I don’t concern myself as much with motive, you know because again … from my area of this in law enforcement we don’t really care so much as to why they did it, as the fact that it did occur.”
Then, he was asked specifically about the ‘witchcraft’ motive, to which he said, “Yes, it is still in play.” Although in this press conference, he himself did not use the term ‘witchcraft’ or any related words. Sheriff Morgan did, however, clearly note that there was evidence in the home that Hartung practiced Witchcraft, and that the suspect made statements supporting that evidence. ECSO would not release any more information, saying that the details will come out in court.
Later that same day, Sheriff Morgan gave an exclusive interview to the local ABC affiliate. In that video, Sheriff Morgan did use the word ‘witchcraft,’ saying “it is still an element of the case.” He elaborated, saying that investigators found “photos, items, physical evidence” suggesting the practice of Witchcraft. Those details along with the July 31 blue moon and the reported “self-admissions” are keeping the Witchcraft theory in play. This interview can be seen in full below.
Despite the arrest and news update, the alleged ‘Witchcraft’ connection still remains mystery to the public. As noted by Sheriff Morgan, there were two other possible theories being pursued as well. One involved R.T. Williams’ connection to the Department of Homeland Security, but that has since been dropped. The third is monetary, or “financial gains.”
Additionally, it is now being reported that the crime scene, originally called ‘ritualistic,’ was not at all staged suspiciously. According News 5, “investigators are now [saying] that the bodies were not found laid out in a ritual pattern. All three bodies were discovered in separate rooms of the house.”
Despite the changing details and downplaying of the ‘Witchcraft’ angle, the media is still working the ‘Occult’ angle, which may be partially due to the upcoming holiday. News reports are now calling the case “the Witchcraft murders.”
Regardless of motivation, it is entirely possible that the suspect did dabble in the Craft in some form. Books and online information are easily accessible to anyone. In fact, local News 5 is now reporting that the victims’ family members state that “Hartung ‘loosely’ practiced some form of witchcraft or Wiccan religion, and kept at least one Wiccan book in his office.” This may be what ECSO found.
We reached out to local Wiccan Priest Rev. Edward Livingston, who said, “[Hartung] is not part of the Pagan community to anyone’s knowledge…. I’ve never heard of him.” Livingston is the founder of the Fire Dance Church of Wicca, the only 501(c)3, Wiccan church in the area. He has lived there for 50 years and been active in the Pagan community for over 20.
Livingston described the Pensacola religious climate as very conservative. He said that it is dominated by the Southern Baptist, Assembly of God, and Pentecostal Churches. He added that there are two Jewish synagogues, a few Catholic churches, one Unity Church and one UU congregation. Due to this atmosphere, most Pagans remain “in the broom closet” and practice in small covens or alone. Livingston said, “We all know solitary practitioners that have never had any training. If it turns out to be this [is] the case maybe its once again a good reason for proper education within our community.”
When asked if there had been any backlash due to the very public ‘Witchcraft’ accusations, Livingston emphatically said “no.” As he explained, this is partly due to the solitary nature of most Pagans in the area. Additionally, he added “[Most locals] saw this as our silly sheriff over speaking He has a history for histrionics and over reaction.”
Livingston himself was outraged by the entire fiasco in August, both with ECSO and in the media. He also said that, to date, no one from ECSO has contacted him, or any other Pagan known to him, to assist with the case or clarify the details about Witchcraft or Wicca.
As announced Tuesday, the so-called ‘Blue Moon’ murder case has now been handed over the the State Attorney’s office, who will be seeking the death penalty due to the number of victims and the situation. Hartung is due in court for a Grand Jury hearing on Nov 18 at 8:30am.
Until the court case makes more details public, there are still questions remaining. Is there really any tangible connection to Witchcraft or Wicca? And, if so, is that Witchcraft connection truly the motivation behind the gruesome act? Or is it simply the religious practice of the suspect – an irrelevant, but very distracting, detail?
The Wild Hunt is not responsible for links to external content.
To join a conversation on this post:
Visit our The Wild Hunt subreddit! Point your favorite browser to https://www.reddit.com/r/The_Wild_Hunt_News/, then click “JOIN”. Make sure to click the bell, too, to be notified of new articles posted to our subreddit.
I’m all for proper education, its easy to get misinformation when looking on your own.
No one talks about the “baseball element” or the “custom motorcycle element” in murders…
It always worries me when people start saying, “he wasn’t known in the Pagan community here” when these kind of things come up. Not everyone is active in the community, not everyone is well known. And sooner or later, there will be a crime, and it will be by someone known to the community, and then we won’t be able to brush this sort of thing off so easily.
So why is that an issue. Its a small community of pagans. We network locally a lot. No we can’t know everyone but we know this guy was not part of our community! and it really does not matter since it had NOTHING to do with Witchcraft at all. Its a crazy sheriff in a small Navy Town. He needs some education about non christian religions but I promise he could careless
Well said Turner
So there were no ritualistic elements, and there’s no pagan ritalistic murder blue moon or no, but it was another sad case of fatal domestic abuse. Murderous domestic abuse. That’s horrific enough but the needy predatory histrionics of law enforcement, and also of “the” media, because such particularly dark titillation sells, are a relection of the public’s lurid fantasy and prejudice.
Who needs any of that? Instead, I ask if the perpetrator was known to the police and did the system fail to protect the perp’s mother and two stepbrothers or was this the first sign of violence in that household? Yes, was there a history of trouble of the domestic kind and what can people do about that? Proactively? The unnecessary drama seems to have too easily thrown multiple parties and the public off that track — what are they afraid of or hiding? Are they afraid to face these topics or just ill-equipped?
Plus, if I remember correctly, the bodies were *found* on the Blue Moon, but murdered earlier, so from the get-go, the case was being sensationalized.
Ah, so they comitted lying by omission too. They omit those details.
i like how you never hear that the crime scene and the abode the suspected perpetrator/s showed signs of christian worship.