Santeria? Satanist? Something Else?

Jason Pitzl-Waters —  December 28, 2009 — 30 Comments

Here we go again. It was just a couple weeks ago that I expressed some concern over the seemingly misinformed animal control and welfare officers employed in the state of Pennsylvania, and now they’re in the news again over a “huge find” in an abandoned house.

“Police are investigating a case of possible animal cruelty after the remains of 75 animals and a large altar composed of primate skulls were found today inside a house in the city’s Feltonville section. The animals are believed to have been sacrificed as part of satanic worship and Santeria rituals, investigators said. Pentagrams were also seen in the house … George Bengal, director of law enforcement for the Pennsylvania SPCA, said the agency’s officers had entered the living room and found an altar constructed of about 50 primate skulls. “This is a huge find,” Bengal said. Those involved in the rituals “usually take the skull and the feet and the blood and drain the blood from the animal. They’ll drink the blood and use the skull and feet as part of the altar.” Neighbors said that a man in his 50s or 60s lived at the property, but that they had not seen anyone there for months.”

Satanism? Santeria? The “altar” found in the house, and the supposed rituals described in making it, don’t follow traditional practices for either faith (indeed, most modern Satanists don’t even sacrifice animals). I’m also curious as to why this is a “huge find” for them. Because it involves so many animal corpses? Or is it because it fits into certain preconceived notions about what those faiths do with animals? Remember, the George Bengal quoted above is the same George Bengal who recently warned of mysterious Winter “high holidays” where animals were sacrificed in large numbers.

“An animal welfare official says a beheaded dog and cat found in Philadelphia appear to be the result of a ritual sacrifice. George Bengal, Pennsylvania Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals director of investigations, said the dog and cat were found … near a bike path in Philadelphia’s Olney neighborhood along with three beheaded chickens. He said he believes the animals were killed elsewhere and the remains dumped where a passer-by found them. Mr. Bengal said there is usually an increase in ritual animal sacrifices at this time of year because of “a lot of high holidays that different groups celebrate.” But he said most of those sacrifices involve goats and chickens.”

So never mind that various experts in religion and animal abuse cases agree that “huge finds” like this usually aren’t manifestations of Santeria or Satanism, but of disturbed individuals (often teens) who usually construct a hodge-podge of half-understood ritualism to justify their aberrant urges and behaviors. Why go with the boring old truth when you can create a darkly sinister religious “other” to battle? Why listen to experts when you can hector innocent Satanists on bogus abuse charges instead? I would really like to know who exactly is training animal control officers and local ASPCA officials in Pennsylvania concerning ritual sacrifice. Do they even know what a normal Santeria ritual is like? Have they even met a real Satanist? This current trend could be heading for a train-wreck of racial and religious profiling that could seriously damage the effectiveness of animal control officials among minority faiths. After all, why report a co-religionist who’s abusing animals if they’ll just think you’re in on it too?

Jason Pitzl-Waters

Posts

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Baruch Baruch

    Jason, the reporter of this story is accessible from an email address at the end of the story. If you were to send her a copy of your post, as part of a regular practice in covering stories like this, you'd be directing germane questions at the journalist who cover them. In time they might begin to ask the critical questions that we'd all like to see them explore. That would limit the influence of these "expert" types.

    Baruch Dreamstalker

    • http://www.blackrosecoven.com/?q=node TeNosce

      Yeah, there should be an "Ask a Pagan" type of website where reporters writing stories could actually pose their questions before committing themselves to their own biases. People, like those gathered here, could chime in their perspectives.

      • http://wachwurd.jimdo.com/ Malaz

        An excellent idea, but most law enforcement isn't ready to deal with us in that context.
        Your standard Sheriff Lo-brow thinks we kill cats in our basement…I mean…come on…they don't luv baby jesus…they must be insane or something.

      • http://intensedebate.com/people/Lokisgodhi Lokisgodhi

        Why limit to just ask a Pagan? There are dozens of topics where the news morons should be asking questions. It's always amusing to watch them do a piece on military equipment and agencies.

        • A.C. Aldag

          Santeros don't have pentacles or pentagrams as their symbol.

          The authorities need to quit hectoring alternative religions and look for some mentally unstable individual, because serial murderers often abuse animals first, then move on to human victims.

          • http://intensedebate.com/people/sari0009 KarenAScofield

            Sadly, that seems to escape them.

        • Pingback: The Wild Hunt » Bloody Death-Pit or Anti-Santeria Vendetta?

      • Pingback: The Wild Hunt » Update: Santeria? Satanism? Something Else?

  • http://www.blackrosecoven.com/?q=node TeNosce

    Actually, it sounds like a Catholic church. :)

    I'm really getting sick of this double standard. Check out Sedlec Ossuary on the Internet. The pictures will blow you away.

    http://images.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://ima

  • Rachel

    This is nothing new for Pennsylvania. This is the same crowd where an overly zealous game warden tried to take a pet squirrel (it was legitimately acquired) into custody and cited the family for having a wild animal. It is all about petty bureaucrats who rise to positions of power and who seek to use their power in the ostensible name of preventing harm. No different that the propaganda promoted by the US government to justify intervention in Afghanistan, Pakistan and elsewhere. This has everything to do with power and contol and nothing to do with Satanism or Santeria.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Apuleius Apuleius

    The BTK killer was an animal control officer.

    I'm just sayin'.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_Rader#Persona

  • http://www.blackrosecoven.com/?q=node TeNosce

    It IS a huge find. Do you have any idea how hard it was to get a primate skull for my Solstice altar this year? After waiting in line for an hour, Bones R' Us told me they won't have any more until at least January.

    And this guy had 50! Bastard.

  • http://rootandrock.blogspot.com Scylla

    My question is how in the hell anyone managed to get a hold of FIFTY primate skulls? What sort of costs would be involved in such a massive undertaking and of course… how will this effect how likely any of this is to be -real-? Let's find out!

    I did some web searches and obtained the following info: For natural bone specimens of primate skulls, the cheapest price I locate was around $200. For museum quality "bone resin" replicas, the price was still a stiff $100. These were for small monkey skulls from rat to cat size. The more impressive baboon will run you between $300-$700. I'm sure that the ASPCA isn't mind-bendingly idiotic enough to mistake cast resin for actual bone, so we can probably rule out the resin casts.

    From just this estimate, of already-dead primate specimens, the "altar" alone would've cost between $5,000 and $15,000 on a conservative estimate (shipping and handling not included). This estimate also does not include feet, which would have to be purchased as full skeletal mounts, increasing the cost by about $200 per specimen.

    Now, were these people actually sacrificing animals as suggested by the boneheaded man in mention, the price climbs considerably. Obtaining live primates (through the pet trade) is as costly and tied up in paperwork as HUMAN adoption, and for good reason. The most inexpensive primate for sale in the pet trade that I could locate was a $1,500 Marmoset (about the size of a rat) The price-range on small monkeys seems to be $1,500 – $5,000 for Marmosets and $10,000 – $20,000 for Capuchins.

    So, in order for these people to have sacrificed all of these animals, we come to an estimate of $75,000 – $1,000,000 for -small- primates. That estimate does not include travel and transportation costs, and also involves a rather huge paper-trail. It also does not include the paper-trail required for transporting and housing wild "Exotic" animals. One would imagine that the cost would climb if you wanted to avoid paperwork.

    I'm also assuming that these skulls are not tiny things (or else they wouldn't be calling them "primate" skulls, but "monkey" skulls, inless they're trying to make it sound as terrifying as possible, and imply humans might be in that mix… HMMM). I'd err toward the higher estimates in any case.

    So, let's say these people or this person, actually did this. Surely an investment of several thousand (up to hundereds of thousands) of dollars would be kept in a protected location. Surely someone with that sort of financial heft behind them could very easily rent a location with strong security systems, and no one would EVER discover what they were up to.

    The idea of (at the least) $5,000 in FAKE osteological specimens or $15,000+ in REAL ones being located in an abandoned house is far too unlikely for me to believe the validity of the claim. The idea that people actually sacrificed that many animals (bringing even a pile of tiny marmoset skulls up to an investment of $75,000) is absolutely laughable. 50 skulls? Sure. I can believe that. It's not very hard for little teen-dabbler kids to pick up strays, or remains from fields. 50 PRIMATE skulls? I call shenanigans, and so should everyone else.

    (Prices and pricing information obtained from google searches for "primate skulls for sale" and "primate pets for sale")

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/thewildhunt Jason Pitzl-Waters

    Nice google-fu there Scylla. I think the “primate” part will be editedout later, when they find it's actually squirrels, rabbits, cats, anddogs, and not 10,000-dollar monkeys.

  • http://www.chasclifton.com/blogger.html Chas S. Clifton

    Ditto. That was my first question–Where on earth do you get them, assuming they are real and not casts. (And good-quality casts are not cheap.)

    There has got to be more here …

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/GreenWaySkull GreenWaySkull

    "I'm sure that the ASPCA isn't mind-bendingly idiotic enough to mistake cast resin for actual bone, so we can probably rule out the resin casts. "

    I wouldn't be to sure of that.
    As far as the bones themselves, they probably aren't as hard to find as you think. More a matter of knowing the right person. Some wild animal import experts think there could be anywhere from 10,000 to 100,000 privatly owned and undocumented primates in North America. Exotic animals are one of the hottest commodities on the black market.
    That being said, a pile of bones does not a pagan alter make.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Hylomorphic Hylomorphic

    Exactly.

    But supposing the story is correct, and there are indeed fifty primate skulls… why would anyone think it has anything to do with animal sacrifice? Sounds more to me like it's connected with black market animal trafficking. I can't think any other way you could get that many exotic animal bones in one place.

    I'd be more likely to conclude that it's inventory rather than an altar.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Teaa Tea

    Probably some disturbed teens rebelling against their Christian parents with some ideas they gleaned from pop horror movies.

  • http://www.robinartisson.com Robin Artisson

    Okay, this isn't Satanism or Santeria. Any informed person knows this already. Sadly, Animal Control and Law Enforcement don't tend to be well informed. And as much as it would be cool to have a Pagan outreach to Law Enforcement in theory, even I wouldn't want it. Why? Because I've known too many Pagans. They'd do nothing but confuse law enforcement and give them their version of the facts. They'd get carried away. There is no possibility of a fair spokesperson for "Pagans" out there for the simple reason that there are as many ways to be pagan, satanist, or a practitioner of santeria, as there are human beings out there. There are no true "experts" of our field, only people who are more or less exposed to the great variety of our ways.

    Now, having said that, it's true that I've never come across anyone who makes altars of primate skulls. And really, if I did, I'd have to tell them how boring I thought they were. Primate skulls are boring. We all have them on top of our spines. Altars made of them would look like piles of round, boring white rocks. Stag and Deer skulls are clearly superior; they look wicked, and interlaced antlers make a bad ass structure.

    If we have to play "animal parts bingo", (I mean, if you haven't gotten out of that sophomoric phase) at least have some style- and- don't be a douche and leave some sensational looking halloweeny shit in an abandoned house where people will find it and get runnymouth to the press. Because now, the causes of other Pagans who are more mature and well-put-together have been set back another five years, and if I caught the people who did it, I'd add another few primate skulls to the pile.

  • Silv

    I can't wait to find out the truth behind this one. An altar made of skulls? really? Sounds like this investigator has been sniffing too much catnip.

  • http://www.blackrosecoven.com/?q=node TeNosce

    "if I caught the people who did it, I'd add another few primate skulls to the pile."

    Priceless.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Lokisgodhi Lokisgodhi

    Robin, you're assuming they'd qualify as primates. Supposition, facts not in evidence.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Apuleius Apuleius

    The BTK killer was an animal control officer.

    I'm just sayin'.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dennis_Rader#Persona

  • whitewolf

    Why do they always assume people who practice Satanism and Santeria are always to blame when this sort of thing happens? It's so stupid.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Lokisgodhi Lokisgodhi

    Not very. There are evidently millions walking around not protecting brain matter. It just a matter of harvesting them. Personally, I recommend a sharp hand and a half claymore.

  • http://rootandrock.blogspot.com Scylla

    Oh, I'm not disputing that unlicensed/undocumented primates exist. I'm debating how much it would cost, and therefore how likely it would be, for someone to obtain fifty of them. The bones are absolutely -easy- to find. Had I the money I could have purchased any number of the natural bones I price-checked. But I don't really have any interest in owning monkey skulls.

    Still, for the fifty quoted… that's a lot of scratch to leave lying around in an abandoned house.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/Lokisgodhi Lokisgodhi

    Last time I checked, squirrels WERE wild animals. The ones in Union Square Park don't cooperate with the local kid's attempts to adopt them. In fact they usually run like, well, they're being chased during the aforetomentioned adoption process. I'm hoping one day the kids will catch one when I'm there and can enjoy watching them get the crap bitten out of them.

    http://lifeisaroad.com/stories/2004/10/27/theDark

    Maybe that's why you don't generally see many down at the pet store. Just how does one acquire a squirrel legally anyway?

  • lonespark

    Exactly what I thought. No indication whether this has been checked out?

  • http://www.red-alerts.com Rob Taylor

    Hmmm. Some rare agreement from me since you’re 100% right about this nonsense. Although I will point out that the idea that every person who does something we don’t like to be associated with is disturbed is a bit of a cop out on our part. I’ve “met” several people in my online travels that consider themselves pagans and sacrifice animals (and not just Heathens) and I know plenty of magicians who use blood in rituals, something that has made a comeback thanks to a book called Blood Magick which has been passed around the armchair occult community for the last couple of years.

    Heck I threw a little cow blood around myself back in the day, though mine was purchased by the pint from a Spanish/Asian market in Jersey. Remember that Afro-carib magical practices were just as influenced by European occultism as anything else, and magical traditions develop in urban centers in interesting ways.

    However the ASPCA though is just parroting New York’s animal rights movement’s racist attacks on Santeria. When I lived there I had a vegan tell me we should deport all the Cubans because they “tortured animals” for their religion. Meh.

    In your last post on this you question whether the old “cult experts” are out stirring the pot. About a month and a half ago a reader of mine passed on a request from some European blog that linked to me to have me contact a reader of theirs who was interested in “occultists” and paganism. That person turned out to be Linda Blood who authored the book The New Satanists back in the early 90s. After a terse (yet polite) exchange of emails where I implied her life’s work amounted to being a laughing stock and she strongly suggested that I was ignorant of “them” we bid each other farewell. I was left with the impression that Blood, Ted Gunderson and the rest of the SRA ilk had congealed around the whole Prison Planet culture and were peddling the 9/11truth/NAU/NWO stuff for a good deal of the last decade. They seem to have quite the little following on both sides of the political spectrum; Blood on the right, Gunderson ran an anti-Bush site for awhile.

    It’s been largely ignored but I think the “ritual experts” have wormed their way into the fringes of a bunch of sub-cultures. I have even met a pagan who believed in S.R.A. My impression from my conversation with Blood was that they were preparing for another push. Maybe one of them got hired to do a workshop?